The Bread Baker ' s Apprentice Challenge: Bagels (Week 3)

Some say that the first known bagel was baked in Austria in 1683 when a baker from Vienna, thankful to the King of Poland for saving Austria from Turkish invaders, reshaped the local bread so that it resembled the King’s stirrup. Others say that the bagel was invented much earlier in Krakow, Poland, as a competitor to the obwarzanek, a lean bread of wheat flour designed for Lent. It was originally called a “beugel,” derived from the German word stirrup, “bugel.”

Living near New York, I know how much people like their bagels. I know that many New Yorkers are even fiercely protective of the idea that New York makes the best bagel. And I won't pretend that I've never had fantasies about the whole-wheat everything bagels from Murray's on Sixth Avenue.

People like bagels so much that in 2008, Canadian-born astronaut Gregory Chamitoff brought the first known batch of bagels into space on a mission to the International Space Station. Don't quote me on it, but that is the word on the street.

Even though you can't bake a bagel in space, most people don't realize that they don't need to travel far and wide to get their hands on a delicious bagel. You can make authentic, New York-style bagels in your own kitchen. And before you start laughing I'm going to tell you that it's EASY. Time consuming, yes, but also simple and worth the effort

For the Bread Baker's Apprentice Challenge, this week we've been charged with making water-boiled bagels from a simple recipe that calls for little more than white or whole grain bread flour, salt and malt syrup. Since I didn't have the latter ingredient I successfully substituted honey.

For toppings, I used coarse salt and sesame seeds, but let it be said that i never expected them to turn out good. I didn't think I'd blow them up or anything but I didn't expect bagels that looked and tasted like they'd come from a bakery. I like bagels best when they're slightly chewy and warm - but not so warm that it melts the butter or cream cheese. These bagels delivered on all counts with an unexpected bonus - a great aroma that filled my apartment on an otherwise lazy Sunday morning.

As usual, we're not posting the recipes to every kind of bread that we bake but similar recipes are available around the internet and if you have any questions about the recipes I’ve used feel free to email me with questions. For more resources on baking bagels, feel free to visit these sites:

Sugarlaws - Bagels
Tammy's Recipes - Homemade Bagels
Under the High Chair - DIY: Bagel Tutorial & More History
Wild Yeast - Sourdough Bagels

Comments

[Susan]

These look awesome. I love me some bagels. I've tried to make them a few times, but haven't quite gotten the hang of it yet.

[sara]

Your bagels look awesome--totally gorgeous! Yum. :) Great to be baking along with you. :)

[Shari]

These look totally professional -- only they taste way better, right? I thought they were fun to make. Enjoyed your post.

[Kitchen Goddess]

OMG Maris those bagels look perfect, a really professional job :) Very informative and interesting post too.

[Kerstin]

They look perfect - great job!

[Chelsea Talks Smack]

mmmm now I'm craving bread. AT 2 AM.

[Lorraine @ Not Quite Nigella]

They look perfect Maris! I have to admit the best ever bagel I had was in NY. It was snowing and I had a bacon, egg and cheese bagel for breakfast. I felt like I had died and gone to heaven! :)

[8 Women Dream]

Is anyone ever going to make a decent gluten free one? I miss bread and sooo cannot have it.
C

[Carissa]

those bagels look perfect! just like from a bakery. I don't think I will be making any at home any time soon, but you have inspired me to get some freshly baked bagels this weekend! :) to top it off, you made my favorite kind of bagels: sesame! (my second favorite are the ones rolled in oats... yum! maybe I'll get two.)

[magda]

Impressive! I've never thought to make my own bagels. I can't think they'd come out as neatly as this, but maybe something I'll try at some point!

I also loved the way you wrote this post. I learned so much!

[Cora @ Cora Cooks]

Maris, your bagels are stunning! I could eat one right now. It's been a long time since I made them at home but, with your inspiration, I might just have to try it again.

[Jessica]

Wow those look really good. Nice work. I would like to buy one, how much?

[Susie]

Your bagels look great. Great job,
Susie

[Jenn @ Pete Eatemall]

I loved this recipe..your looks great..I will have to make some now that I am home - that will make batch number 3 1/2...Makes me wish I had a bagel now...happy baking!

[Catherine]

The biggest culture shock moving from NYC to LA is the bagel. Can't get a good one here! Yours look fantastic...

[ksgoodeats]

Oh my goodness, I LOVE bagels and those look incredible!!

[Sophie]

MMMMM...Maris: your bagels look just perfect! yum Yum Yum!

[thatShortChick]

oooohh freshly-baked bagels! I miss them SO MUCH.

It's near impossible to get a quality bagel here in Charlotte (although people have been telling me that I'm wrong about that. so far, from what i've tasted, my theory still stands).

[alexandra]

There is nothing like a New York bagel. I miss bagels so much, though my town's bagel shop (Bagel Shack) is pretty awesome. I have made this recipe. It is fabulous! so worth the effort

[elra]

Well done Maris! You beat me hear. I never made Bagel before, maybe I should try. I have the book, I shall wait no more!

[mandy]

I have been wanting to make bagels since I found a recipe about a month or so ago. Can you please email me the recipe you used? The fewer ingredients the better, the other recipe was kind of complicated and scared me. =)

[kat]

Those look perfect!

[doggybloggy]

first rate bagels - wow you got the shape and color down perfect

[Jamie]

Wow, Maris, your bagels are beautiful! They look like the best New York bagels I've ever eaten! Okay, you have convinced me to give bagels one more try....